It would be ridiculous and, worse, boring. In A Visit from the Goon Squadthe second-person protagonist attempts to turn his friend Drew against another friend Sasha. Because of this, arguments are most effective when the reader already knows a character and understand their goals.
Same goes for emotional drama. Different lines may pull towards different outcomes, but each is significant because the reader wants one outcome more than another.
Not only do they want that character to be okay or want them to succeedbut they understand what each moment means as it happens. Reading a great argument is like watching amazing sport, but reading a bad one is like being stuck in a car with an unhappy couple. Each point is a punch, each rebuttal a block or reversal.
Rather, I mean that in terms of their mechanics, writing an argument follows all the same rules as writing a fight scene. Authors will giddily write a chapter-long tirade or page-spanning battletotally confident that the reader will be rendered breathless by the skill and passion on display, and completely wrong in that assumption.
An accusation unanswered is a bloody lip, and all the while, the reader needs some idea of how much each combatant can take, and what they want. Escalate the argument If each statement drags the characters towards an outcome, then each statement has to matter.
For an argument to be truly compelling, the reader needs to understand every line of dialogue as a force pulling the characters towards a specific outcome.
Wait until the reader cares In writing, arguments and fight scenes are all about the result. This is actually one of the most important tips for writing a compelling argument: An argument is a fight scene — what works for one will benefit the other. Click To Tweet Vitally, each of the statements in an argument make up a journey.
Often, if your story follows a protagonist, it can be tempting to have them run up against obstacles that are just there to slow them down or make their goal harder. Robin Childs, creator of the webcomic LeyLinesputs it like this: For an argument to work, the reader needs some idea of how it could end.
No-one who really wants something holds back like that. Both parties should want something from the other. The breathless drama is in guessing and second-guessing the consequences — will they be okay, and what does each new moment of the argument mean for their overall goal?Writing Spaces Open Textbook Chapters.
Each of these titles is available under a Creative Commons license (consult the individual text for the license specifics). Click on the title to view the chapter abstract and a downloadable PDF of the chapter. argument, audience, description, detail, invention, metaphor, purpose, show vs.
tell. Show more Argument & Persuasion Textbooks Also at This Level: Analytic Reading, College Reading Skills, College Writing Skills, Education & Reading Skills, Education & Writing Skills, Reading & Writing References & Resources, Reading Comprehension, Reading Poetry, Thesis & Dissertation Writing, Writing the Research Paper.
Writing Arguments: A Rhetoric with Readings, 10/e integrates four different approaches to argument: the enthymeme as a logical structure, the classical concepts of logos, pathos, and ethos, the Toulmin system, and stasis theory.
Focusing on argument as dialogue in search of solutions instead of a pro-con debate with winners and losers, it. Writing Arguments: A Rhetoric with Readings / Edition 9 The market leader in argumentative rhetoric/readers, Writing Arguments has been praised for its clear explanation of the Toulmin model, separate chapters on reading and writing arguments, and a wealth of interesting student and professional examples.2/5(1).
Throughout the book, the authors approach argument rhetorically by emphasizing audience and context at every stage in the construction of an argument.
Writing Arguments moves students beyond a simplistic debate model of argument to a view of argument as inquiry and consensus-building as well as persuasion, in which the writer. Arguments in academic writing are usually complex and take time to develop.
Your argument will need to be more than a simple or obvious statement such as “Frank Lloyd Wright was a great architect.”.Download