Edna, throughout the novel shows that she is subject to her irrational whims and emotions rather than consciously making carefully reasoned choices to shape her own destiny.
Both of these novels show human beings to be without free will and unable to shape their destiny, though this is presented in different ways. In The Awakening, Chopin seems to offer a somewhat different message about free will vs.
This is shown most clearly by the ending, while the correspondent, who is one of the weakest of the characters and who knows least about the sea, survives, whilst the oiler, who is much stronger than the other characters, dies: For her, this remains a fantasy because independence, for a woman of her station, is a foreign concept.
However, she feels that it would be impossible. In "The Open Boat," the might of nature shows man to be puny and infinitely fragile.
One very stark difference between Edna Pontellier and Nora Helmer is the social environments from which each woman comes. Although in some ways Edna could be viewed as a perfect example of free will, when the text is examined closer, she seems a curious victim of her whims and emotions that master her and overwhelm her.
Though she walks out into the sea, her act is a rather passive one—she allows the waters to overtake her so that she no longer has to choose. The message of Crane is clear: In the shallows, face downward, lay the oiler. The metaphor to the sea and its waves is no accident remembering how Edna ends her life.
There is a moment in the novel in which Edna contemplates His forehead touched sand that was periodically, between each wave, clear of the sea. There is also the possible metaphor of the Gulf of Mexico—a warm, soupy body of water at night—with the womb. The pursuit of self-discovery is active. Therefore this novel again presents humans as being more subject to determinism than being able to make their own decisions, though this is in a different way from the way in which brute, overpowering nature is shown to operate in "The Open Boat.
The men left stranded in a boat have to face the fact that there is nothing that they can do to shape their destiny and to give them a better chance of survival. Nora walks out of her home and claims a life of agency in an effort to discover who she is.
Note the following description of how the music of Chopin works upon her: Though both are middle-class, married women with children, Edna is a product of the social hierarchy of New Orleans.
White women did not have the sexual freedom of their male counterparts, they could not stray far from home without being in the company of their husbands, and they had little financial independence.
She trembled, she was choking, and the tears blinded her.How would you compare Kate Chopin's The Awakening to Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter? Get an answer for 'Compare/contrast two characters: Edna in The Awakening (novel) by Kate Chopin, and Nora in A Doll's House (play) by Henrik Ibsen.' and find homework help for other The Awakening.
Compare and contrast ideas, themes, and important points from The Awakening by Kate Chopin. Part of a comprehensive Study Guide by killarney10mile.com Free Essay: Comparing Awakenings in Chopin's The Storm and The Story of an Hour As a forerunner of the modern feminist movement, Kate Chopin explored bold.
Compare Story Of The Hour To The Awakening. Story of An Hour and The Awakening Compare and Contrast Essay Kate Chopin's literary works, "Story of An Hour" and "The Awakening" are very similar in their strong feministic voice, the mood of discontentedness, and the prevailing theme of the search for freedom from a culture dominated by male.
Get an answer for 'Compare and contrast "The Open Boat" with The Awakening, with reference to self-determination and free-will.' and find homework help for other The Awakening, The Open Boat.Download